I cannot believe the tragedy that was distilled into the first moments of this prelude, BWV 853. It is as if one is holding drinking glass, and the next second drops and shatters it. It is heartbreaking each time I hear it. But what I hear is the playing of Richter when I listen to this. The missing quality that Carlos Gardels doesn’t supply, my mind fools me to add in.
It is like the blind spot built into our eye that when we actually see a broken green circle or broken red line because of the optic nerve attached in one spot, our mind translates it to a complete green circle or complete red line.
But this is not a criticism of Gardels, it was once well said that “It is unfair to compare another pianist to Richter, unfair for the other pianist.”
But when a person unfamiliar with the piece comes across a competent recording or performance, and then walks away thinking the music is nothing special, soft and moody, but not Wow! Is it unfair to that person… to Bach?
It reminds me of hearing a masterclass with the great cellist Bernard Greenhouse. The student plays. The audience listens and thinks she was perfect. Then Greenhouse plays the same piece to show how its done and everyone realizes at that moment that the student did a great injustice to the work.
Download 1stpiano's most popular solo piano music! 11 tracks including Beethoven's Moonlight Sonata, Debussy's Clair de Lune, Bach, Liszt, Mozart and more.
Recent Comments
fannas احب المقطوعات الكلاسيكية بلا اشتثناء وافضلها على سواهخا من المقطوعات الموسيقية على السواء
Miss Clown Feet I promise to stop stealing moments of your life when you stop stealing so many moments of mine. Although, I can’t really complain, because everytime you steal a moment-my...
About
1stpiano.com was launched in 2007 with the aim to provide streaming classical piano music for free. Many of the recordings available on 1stpiano.com have been performed and published by founder Jorgos. Additional recordings have been either gathered from public domain projects, or embedded from YouTube. To contact 1stpiano.com, please leave a message here.
lomejor del piano
I cannot believe the tragedy that was distilled into the first moments of this prelude, BWV 853. It is as if one is holding drinking glass, and the next second drops and shatters it. It is heartbreaking each time I hear it. But what I hear is the playing of Richter when I listen to this. The missing quality that Carlos Gardels doesn’t supply, my mind fools me to add in.
It is like the blind spot built into our eye that when we actually see a broken green circle or broken red line because of the optic nerve attached in one spot, our mind translates it to a complete green circle or complete red line.
But this is not a criticism of Gardels, it was once well said that “It is unfair to compare another pianist to Richter, unfair for the other pianist.”
But when a person unfamiliar with the piece comes across a competent recording or performance, and then walks away thinking the music is nothing special, soft and moody, but not Wow! Is it unfair to that person… to Bach?
It reminds me of hearing a masterclass with the great cellist Bernard Greenhouse. The student plays. The audience listens and thinks she was perfect. Then Greenhouse plays the same piece to show how its done and everyone realizes at that moment that the student did a great injustice to the work.
it feels like leaving someone you don’t like to leave but needed as if he was crying while playing it really is a sad song
Para quien Habla español se abre un mundo nuevo (el Viejo Mundo) al oir a los compositores clasicos . . .
SUBLIME!!!! Un grande entre los grandes…
Wonderful!!!!!!!!!
Second guessing and sorrow interspersed by moments of tragety.
Beautiful
Simplesmente maravilhoso
esta es verdadera musica es magnifica me encanta es delicada pero fuerte a la vez
SUBLIME!!!! Un grande entre los grandes…